Comparison 2026

HR and project time in one tool, from 5 € per user

MetronHR against 23 vendors. Price, features up to the payroll handover to the accountant, server location and operator side by side in one table.

No credit card required · Cancel monthly

23 Providers at a glance

Six criteria that come first in a selection conversation. Every row leads to the full comparison with prices, server location and sources.

ProviderPrice fromServers in DEOperator not a US groupHR fileShift planProject timePrice publicFeatures
MetronHRfrom 5 €/user18/18
absence.iofrom 2.99 euros/user, time tracking from 4.99 euros9/18
askDANTEa free plan, otherwise from 4.50 euros/user~~~12/18
aworkfrom 5 euros/user7/18
Clockify and Toggl Trackfree, paid from 3.99 dollars or 9 euros~4/18
clockinfrom 3.59 euros/user on a 24-month term~~12/18
Clockodofrom 4 euros/user, without a personnel file11/18
Crewmeisterfrom 1.50 euros/user, modules extra~9/18
Factorialfrom 8 euros/user, quoted individually~~12/18
gastromaticfrom 69.50 euros a month8/18
HRworksfrom 12.90 euros/user11/18
Kenjofrom 6 euros/user plus setup from 400 euros~~10/18
MEP24from 99 euros a month~9/18
Ordiofrom 89 euros per site per month~~10/18
Papershiftfrom 4 euros/user plus 39 euros a month for support~~~11/18
PersonioPrice on request~11/18
Plandayfrom 2.99 euros/user, from 5 people~9/18
Planerioon request~~7/18
Sage HR Suitefrom 21 euros a month per module~~10/18
Shiftbase0 euros up to 15 users, then from 30 euros a month~~7/18
Timebutlerfrom 29.95 euros a month~9/18
TimeTacfrom a 19.50 euro monthly base fee~12/18
timrfrom 8 euros/user, from 20 people on request~11/18
ZEPfrom 2 euros/user, modules extra~11/18

~ = available with limits. What exactly is limited is stated with a source and the date retrieved on the relevant comparison page. – = no verified information is available on this.

The price column shows the provider's entry price, not the price for the same scope. With several providers, modules, base fees, support flat rates or one-off setup costs are added, and the figures come in different units: per user, per month, per site or on request. For orientation: ten people cost with MetronHR 50 € on the Team plan and 100 € on Professional, with no base fee, no setup charge and no minimum purchase. The like-for-like comparison is on the relevant comparison page.

Six of 18 criteria. The full list per vendor, including working time models, allowances, the check against the Working Hours Act and the payroll handover to the accountant, is on each comparison page.

As at September 2026. All information comes from the official provider pages and their privacy policies. absence.io, askDANTE, awork, Clockify and Toggl Track, clockin, Clockodo, Crewmeister, Factorial, gastromatic, HRworks, Kenjo, MEP24, Ordio, Papershift, Personio, Planday, Planerio, Sage HR Suite, Shiftbase, Timebutler, TimeTac, timr and ZEP are trademarks of their respective owners.

Why teams choose MetronHR

Five reasons that make the difference in every comparison.

  • HR and project time in one tool

    Time tracking, absences, personnel files, onboarding and project time tracking, all on one platform. No second tool, no duplicate maintenance.

  • Transparent prices from 5 €

    Clearly visible on the website. No sales calls, no hidden modules, no base fee. What you see is what you pay.

  • Ready in 5 minutes

    Create an account, invite employees, get going. No weeks-long onboarding process, no mandatory training.

  • Made & hosted in Germany

    GDPR compliant, hosted in German data centres. Compliance with the Working Time Act and the Federal Labour Court ruling on recording working time.

  • Real client allowances

    Create hour packages for clients, track usage in real time, renew automatically, in the comparison shown here only with MetronHR.

Features in detail

FeatureMetronHRClockodoCrewmeisterPersonioHRworksTimeTac
Traffic-light account (warning levels with an automatic alert)12~3~4~5
Working-time models (part-time, flexitime, trust-based working time)~6~7
Shift and duty planning / roster8910111213
Project time tracking / budgets~14~15
Allowances / hour packages~1617181920
Digital Employee File212223
Onboarding and offboarding workflows242526
Analytics & reports~27~28~29
Application hosted in Germany3031323334
Hosting operator without a US parent company3536373839~40
Mobile app~41
API4243
Sources and notes (43)
  1. Clockodo, Traffic-light account (warning levels with an automatic alert): The page on the hours account shows plus and minus hours against target time, without warning levels and without an alert when a limit is exceeded (clockodo.com/de/funktionen/stundenkonto, retrieved 14 September 2026). Clockodo does have thresholds with email notification on the Plus plan, but they apply to the project budget, not the working-time account.
  2. Crewmeister, Traffic-light account (warning levels with an automatic alert): The help article on the time account describes calculation, history, correction and payout of the overtime balance. A warning or alert when a limit is exceeded is not listed there (support.crewmeister.com, article „Das Zeitkonto“, retrieved 14 September 2026).
  3. Personio, Traffic-light account (warning levels with an automatic alert): The overtime balance can be shown as a column in the employee overview and coloured by thresholds you set yourself. The automatic alert is missing: asked about an email to managers from 40 hours, Personio answers in its own community that this cannot currently be automated (community.personio.de, post „Überstundenampel/Hinweis“, retrieved 14 September 2026).
  4. HRworks, Traffic-light account (warning levels with an automatic alert): HRworks mentions „automatic warnings for managers and admins when target hours are exceeded or undercut“. The automatic alert is therefore evidenced, while several graduated warning levels in the manner of a traffic-light account are not mentioned on the product page (hrworks.de/produkt/zeiterfassung-online, retrieved 14 September 2026).
  5. TimeTac, Traffic-light account (warning levels with an automatic alert): TimeTac warns automatically in the hours statement when stored requirements have not been met. A traffic-light account with several named warning levels does not appear on the product page, however; the term appears only in its own time tracking glossary (timetac.com/de/personalzeiterfassung, retrieved 14 September 2026).
  6. Clockodo, Working-time models (part-time, flexitime, trust-based working time): Individual daily target hours per weekday and flexitime via hours accounts, no shift planning (early/late/night) and no A/B weeks.
  7. Crewmeister, Working-time models (part-time, flexitime, trust-based working time): The feature overview mentions an overtime account, automatic break deduction and time off in lieu. Freely configurable working-time models with flexitime, trust-based working time or alternating weekly patterns are not listed there (crewmeister.com/de/funktionsuebersicht, retrieved 2 September 2026).
  8. MetronHR, Shift and duty planning / roster: An optional module, included in the Professional plan and activated per company, either as shift planning or as duty planning with a day plan. MetronHR also works entirely without both.
  9. Clockodo, Shift and duty planning / roster: The feature overview lists working time recording, time clock, hours account, absences, project time and invoicing. A duty or shift roster is not listed there (clockodo.com/de/funktionen, retrieved 3 September 2026).
  10. Crewmeister, Shift and duty planning / roster: The shift planner is a separate module and costs an extra 2 euros per user per month and up; it is included in none of the three time tracking packages (crewmeister.com/de/preise, retrieved 2 September 2026).
  11. Personio, Shift and duty planning / roster: No native shift planning, available only through external marketplace integrations.
  12. HRworks, Shift and duty planning / roster: No native shift planning; HRworks points to an external partner integration for that.
  13. TimeTac, Shift and duty planning / roster: TimeTac records working time but does not plan it. The provider does not list shift or duty planning among its modules.
  14. Crewmeister, Project time tracking / budgets: The packages mention „project reporting“ and, in the Pro package, „extended project time tracking“. Project budgets with a target-actual comparison, client hourly rates and billable activities are not named in the feature overview.
  15. Personio, Project time tracking / budgets: Working time can be split across projects, without separate fields for client and activity.
  16. Clockodo, Allowances / hour packages: Project and interval budgets with periodic reset exist; client-bound hour packages with roll-over do not.
  17. Crewmeister, Allowances / hour packages: The feature overview lists project reporting, the time account and time off in lieu. It does not mention client-bound hour packages with renewal and carry-over (crewmeister.com/de/funktionsuebersicht, retrieved 3 September 2026).
  18. Personio, Allowances / hour packages: Personio creates projects in the settings and releases them for time tracking; reporting runs through the attendance report with a filter per project. A client as a separate object, an hour package per client and renewal with carry-over are not part of it (Personio help on project-based time tracking, checked 3 September 2026).
  19. HRworks, Allowances / hour packages: The product page on time tracking describes booking working time against „projects and sub-projects“. It does not mention client-bound hour packages with periodic renewal and carry-over, nor client hourly rates or budgets as separate fields (hrworks.de/produkt/zeiterfassung-online, retrieved 3 September 2026).
  20. TimeTac, Allowances / hour packages: Project times can be recorded and analysed. Client-bound hour packages with periodic renewal and carry-over of unused hours are not documented.
  21. Clockodo, Digital Employee File: The feature overview mentions absence management and digital holiday requests. A personnel file with contracts, salary data and documents is not in it; for personnel administration Clockodo points to separate HR systems (clockodo.com/de/funktionen, retrieved 3 September 2026).
  22. Crewmeister, Digital Employee File: Crewmeister manages employee master data for time tracking. Contracts, salary data, document upload with expiry reminders and employee self-service are not part of the documented scope.
  23. TimeTac, Digital Employee File: No digital personnel file is named on the home page, the module overview or the pricing page. TimeTac manages employees for time management, not as a personnel file with contracts and documents.
  24. Clockodo, Onboarding and offboarding workflows: A joining or leaving process with tasks, owners and deadlines is not listed in the feature overview (clockodo.com/de/funktionen, retrieved 3 September 2026).
  25. Crewmeister, Onboarding and offboarding workflows: The feature overview mentions a free setup service for the business. A joining or leaving process per person, with tasks, owners and deadlines, is not listed (crewmeister.com/de/funktionsuebersicht, retrieved 3 September 2026).
  26. TimeTac, Onboarding and offboarding workflows: TimeTac's „onboarding service“ is a paid service for setting up your own account, not a workflow for new employees joining.
  27. Crewmeister, Analytics & reports: Excel export, project reporting and a live view for administrators are included. In OMR reviews, rigid reports without flexible filters are the most frequently named criticism.
  28. Personio, Analytics & reports: Reports and analytics are included; native, multi-dimensional project and client reports are limited, however.
  29. HRworks, Analytics & reports: Standard reporting included; multi-dimensional, freely filterable reports with an Excel export are not part of the standard scope.
  30. MetronHR, Application hosted in Germany: The application and customer data run at Hetzner Online GmbH in Nuremberg and Falkenstein, exclusively in Germany.
  31. Clockodo, Application hosted in Germany: Microsoft Azure cloud at two locations in Germany, Frankfurt and Berlin, with emergency backups at Hetzner.
  32. Crewmeister, Application hosted in Germany: The application runs at Amazon Web Services in Frankfurt am Main. The server location is therefore in Germany.
  33. Personio, Application hosted in Germany: In its own privacy policy Personio promises the European Union, not Germany. A data centre in Germany is promised nowhere.
  34. HRworks, Application hosted in Germany: Server location Dublin, Ireland, by its own account. EU and GDPR compliant, but not in Germany.
  35. MetronHR, Hosting operator without a US parent company: The operator is Hetzner Online GmbH, a German company with no US parent. This marketing website is hosted with Vercel, Inc. (USA) in the Frankfurt region, where no employee data is processed.
  36. Clockodo, Hosting operator without a US parent company: The data centres are in Germany, but they are operated by Microsoft. Microsoft discontinued the trustee model with T-Systems, which placed access under a German data trustee, in 2021.
  37. Crewmeister, Hosting operator without a US parent company: The operator is Amazon Web Services, a US group. Crewmeister names AWS as a sub-processor in its own GDPR statement.
  38. Personio, Hosting operator without a US parent company: The operator is Amazon Web Services, a US group. The application at app.personio.de is delivered via Amazon CloudFront.
  39. HRworks, Hosting operator without a US parent company: The operator is Amazon Web Services, a US group. HRworks itself names AWS as a sub-processor.
  40. TimeTac, Hosting operator without a US parent company: TimeTac names Germany as its main server location and further locations in EU countries, but names no operator. The provider is TimeTac GmbH from Graz, so a company with no US parent.
  41. HRworks, Mobile app: Only a responsive web app; HRworks does not offer a native iOS or Android app.
  42. MetronHR, API: The open REST API v1 is part of the Professional plan: readable are employees, departments, clients, services, projects, time entries, absences and published shifts, while clients, services, projects, time entries and absences can be changed, each secured by keys with permissions per resource. Outgoing webhooks and the MCP server for AI assistants also belong to Professional. Sign-in via Microsoft Entra ID comes with every plan. Further integrations are agreed individually in the Enterprise offer.
  43. Crewmeister, API: Crewmeister lists the DATEV connection as its only interface. An open API for your own connections is not documented in the feature overview.

~ = available with limits, the notes are below the table. – = no verified information is available for this provider on this feature. That is not a no: we only record a negative where we can cite a source.

An overview of which features exist at all, regardless of plan. The price-performance comparison is on the pricing page, the individual features in detail under Features.

Feature comparison as at September 2026. Information about competitors comes from publicly available sources, in each case the official provider pages with the date retrieved, and can change. Clockodo, Crewmeister, Personio, HRworks and TimeTac are trademarks of their respective owners.

MetronHR is also available as a native app for iOS and Android:

MetronHR on the App StoreMetronHR on Google Play

Where the data sits

Server location and operator are two different questions. A data centre in Germany does not remove the data from US law: providers with a US parent company fall under the CLOUD Act and the surveillance powers of FISA 702, regardless of where the servers stand. Microsoft's chief legal officer in France testified under oath before the French Senate's committee of inquiry on 10 June 2025 that he could not guarantee that data from European data centres would not go to US authorities (record of the Sénat). That is why both are shown side by side here, each with the source it comes from.

What is compared is what the provider documents for its own application, not the infrastructure of its marketing website. More about our own hosting is in the Trust Center.

  • MetronHR

    Server location of the application
    Hetzner Online GmbH, Nuremberg and Falkenstein. All servers stand exclusively in Germany.
    Operator and legal jurisdiction
    Hetzner Online GmbH, a German company with no US parent and therefore beyond the reach of the CLOUD Act and FISA 702. No US provider sits in the data path for the application.
    Processors outside Germany
    None for the application. Payment is handled by Stripe Payments Europe (Ireland). This marketing website is hosted with Vercel, Inc. (USA, Frankfurt region), and analytics run through PostHog Cloud EU and the reverse proxy cdn.metronhr.de with a Cloudflare edge. No employee data is processed there.
    Source
    MetronHR privacy policyAs at 08/2026
  • Clockodo

    Server location of the application
    Microsoft Azure cloud, two separate locations in Germany, Frankfurt and Berlin. Emergency database backups at Hetzner Online GmbH.
    Operator and legal jurisdiction
    Microsoft, a US group. The application runs in the Azure region Germany West Central. Microsoft discontinued the trustee model with T-Systems in 2021 and has operated the German regions itself since then.
    Processors outside Germany
    None named for the application. For the website and operations the privacy policy lists, among others, Google, Microsoft, Stripe, Sentry and Hotjar, based on standard contractual clauses.
    Source
    clockodo Trust Center abgerufen 08/2026
  • Crewmeister

    Server location of the application
    Amazon Web Services, central European zone. Crewmeister names Frankfurt am Main as the location of the data centre and undertakes that no data is transferred to non-EU countries.
    Operator and legal jurisdiction
    Amazon Web Services, a US group, and therefore within the scope of the CLOUD Act and FISA 702. The controller is ATOSS ALOUD GmbH, a company of ATOSS Software SE.
    Processors outside Germany
    The GDPR page lists Amazon Web Services and 1Blue Hosting as sub-processors and states that processors from the USA are certified under the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework. The full list is in Annex III of the data processing agreement.
    Source
    Crewmeister, GDPR and data processing abgerufen 02.09.2026
  • Personio

    Server location of the application
    AWS data centres in the European Union. A location in Germany is not promised.
    Operator and legal jurisdiction
    Amazon Web Services, a US group. The application is delivered via Amazon CloudFront. Personio Corp in the USA is also involved as a group company.
    Processors outside Germany
    The full list of processors is visible only after logging in to the Personio account. The privacy policy names Personio Corp in the USA, based on the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework.
    Source
    Personio privacy policy abgerufen 08/2026
  • HRworks

    Server location of the application
    Amazon Web Services in Dublin, Ireland. Within the EU, but not in Germany.
    Operator and legal jurisdiction
    Amazon Web Services, a US group. HRworks encrypts the data with the AWS Key Management Service so that, by its own account, AWS cannot read it.
    Processors outside Germany
    AWS as a sub-processor in Ireland, plus heyData GmbH in Berlin as external data protection officer.
    Source
    HRworks privacy policy abgerufen 08/2026
  • TimeTac

    Server location of the application
    Exclusively data centres within the EU, with the main server location in Germany. For resilience TimeTac runs further locations in other EU countries with live replication and daily backups.
    Operator and legal jurisdiction
    Not named. The provider is TimeTac GmbH from Graz, Austria, with no US parent. TimeTac is certified to ISO 27001 and carries the „Certified Cloud“ seal of the German Cloud Ecosystem programme.
    Processors outside Germany
    The data protection page names none for the application. For the website and operations the consent manager includes Cloudflare, Google, Microsoft, HubSpot, Hotjar, Segment, Zoho and Datadog, among others.

All information comes from the providers' publicly available privacy policies and security pages, and the date retrieved is on every card. Providers can change their infrastructure and their processors at any time. The adequacy decision on the EU-US Data Privacy Framework still applies, but is under legal challenge.

Detailed comparisons

One page per provider with prices, server location, feature gaps and sources.

Time tracking for SMEs

Time tracking as the main product; HR topics such as personnel files and onboarding are rarely included.

HR-Suiten

Personnel administration at the centre, with time tracking as one module of it. Usually without public prices, often with a minimum term.

Duty and shift planning

The duty roster and shift staffing at the centre, usually built for hospitality, retail and care.

Project time and agency software

Projects, budgets and billing at the centre. Working time law and personnel files stay outside.

International free tools

Free basic plans, English-language support, hosting outside the EU. German working time law is not represented.

Ready to switch?

Start for free and see for yourself, no credit card.

  • No credit card required
  • Ready quickly
  • Cancel monthly
  • Full access to every feature

Up and running in 5 minutes