Codetermination
Codetermination means a measure requires the works council's consent. For working time it is governed by section 87(1) BetrVG and is enforceable.
As of:September 2026
The relevant numbers
No. 2: the start and end of daily working time including breaks, and the distribution of working time across the days of the week. That covers rosters, flexitime frameworks and core times.
No. 3: the temporary shortening or extension of the customary working time. That covers ordered extra work and short-time work.
No. 6: the introduction and use of technical devices intended to monitor behaviour or performance. Under settled case law, objective suitability for monitoring is enough; no intention is required. Every time recording system meets that.
No. 14: the arrangement of mobile working, in the act since 2021.
What the 2022 order changed
Before 13/09/2022 it was disputed whether the works council can demand the introduction of time recording. The Federal Labour Court decided: it can no longer, because the duty already exists by law. A right of initiative requires a regulatory gap free of codetermination, and there is none here.
This regularly gets presented the other way round in the market. The correct position is: the order took the right of initiative away from the works council, it did not grant it. Codetermination over the arrangement is entirely unaffected.
MetronHR works these figures out itself: time accounts, premiums, overtime and the limits of the German Working Hours Act, with every booking.
When no agreement is reached
In the cases under section 87(1) BetrVG the conciliation board decides, and its ruling replaces the agreement between the employer and the works council (section 87(2) BetrVG). Codetermination is therefore enforceable, unlike a mere right to be heard in other areas.
A measure introduced without the required consent is ineffective as against the employees. A breach can also lead to a prohibition on using evidence, but need not: on 29/06/2023 (2 AZR 296/22) the Federal Labour Court held that a breach does not automatically make evidence unusable.
Common mistake
Time recording gets introduced and the works council informed afterwards. The whether no longer needs it, the how does, and without an agreement on evaluations and access the introduction is open to challenge.
Further reading
- Section 87(1) nos. 2, 3, 6 and 14 BetrVG, section 87(2) BetrVG
- Federal Labour Court, order of 13/09/2022, 1 ABR 22/21
- Federal Labour Court, judgment of 29/06/2023, 2 AZR 296/22
This is not legal advice; for a specific case at your workplace you are better off asking someone qualified to give it.
Published by: AMNAU GmbH
Editorial responsibility: Ugur Aydogan, Product development.
Last reviewed: September 2026
Knowing the terms is one thing. Settling them cleanly is another.
MetronHR keeps time accounts, calculates premiums and checks the limits of the German Working Hours Act automatically. Try it free for 14 days.
No credit card, cancel any time
Related terms
Works agreement
A works agreement is a written agreement between the employer and the works council. It applies directly and mandatorily to all employees of the business.
Record-keeping duty
The record-keeping duty is the duty to record working times. It follows not from one provision but from several that differ in scope, deadline and addressee.
Duty roster
The roster sets out who works when. Legally it is the exercise of the employer's right to give instructions on the timing of working time.
Processing on behalf
Processing on behalf exists where a service provider processes personal data on behalf of and on the instructions of a controller. It requires a contract under Article 28(3) GDPR.